What's the Secret Behind Magnetic Copy

Copywriting is often thought of as writing that sells, but what actually makes it persuasive has little to do with the writing itself and everything to do with the psychology behind it.

When someone reads a website, an email, or a sales page, they're not making decisions based on facts alone. They're reacting to how something makes them feel, whether they trust the person behind the words, and whether they believe the offer will help them in the way they want to be helped.

The role of psychology in copywriting is to guide people toward a decision by recognizing what they value, what they fear, and what tends to make them hesitate.

One of the biggest influences in copywriting is the way we use social proof. When someone sees that others have already taken a certain action and benefitted from it, it reduces the sense of risk. This is especially helpful when what you are offering is unfamiliar or feels like a big commitment.

Another example is the principle of loss aversion. People are often more motivated to avoid missing out than to gain something new. This is why phrases that hint at something going away or being limited in some way can create a feeling of urgency.

Good copy anticipates questions before someone has to ask them. It addresses concerns without sounding defensive. It makes people feel seen and understood, rather than sold to. This happens through psychology.

For example:

• When someone feels uncertain, they look for simple next steps.
• When something feels overwhelming, they will delay making a decision.
• When they feel like the writer understands their situation, they are more likely to keep reading and eventually take action.

Coaches and consultants who are not in the business world often feel unsure about how to write about their services. They may worry that persuasive writing is manipulative or overly pushy, but when it's rooted in psychology, copywriting becomes a way to make the decision-making process easier for the reader. It respects their time and their intelligence by giving them what they need to make a decision they feel good about.

Real-life examples:

1. Parenting Coach

Before using copy psychology: Her homepage said she helps parents “find balance and connection at home.” Visitors skimmed it and bounced. She wasn’t sure why no one was booking consults.

After using copy psychology: She rewrote her site to speak directly to stressed-out parents who “dread the 3 p.m. school pickup.” She used specific phrases parents say like “I feel like I yell all the time.” 

  2. Grief Counselor

Before: Her email opt-in said “Join my newsletter for tools and inspiration.” No one signed up. She felt discouraged.

After: She rewrote her opt-in to say “When you’re grieving, people don’t always know what to say. I do. I send one short email every week to help you feel less alone.” People replied to say thank you.

  3. Voice Coach for Actors

Before: Her offer was “One-on-one voice lessons for all levels.” It sounded professional but bland. Her site visitors didn’t really engage.

After: She added copy that said, “If you avoid auditions with singing because you’re not confident in your voice, this is for you.” She included a short client story. Now actors DM her saying, “I felt like you were talking directly to me.”

  4. Career Coach for Teachers

Before: Her headline said “Helping you transition to a new role.” She thought it sounded professional. But teachers didn’t understand what it meant or how she could help.

After: She changed it to “Want to leave teaching but don’t know what else you’re qualified for?” Teachers immediately clicked. Her calendar filled with consults.

  5. Creativity Coach for Writers

Before: She promoted her offer as “Weekly coaching to help you write more consistently.” Writers didn’t respond.

After: She used emotional copy: “You’ve been stuck on the same first chapter for months. Let’s finish that draft together, without the pressure to be perfect.” Sign-ups increased and writers said, “This is exactly what I’ve been looking for.”

  6. Body Image Coach for Teens

Before: Her program was described as “Body positivity coaching for teen girls.” Parents didn’t understand what it meant.

After: She reframed it as “Helping your teen change how she talks to herself, so she stops saying ‘I look disgusting’ every time she sees a photo.” Parents reached out with tears and relief.

  7. Wellness Consultant for Nurses

Before: She wrote social posts with tips like “Remember to hydrate and stretch during your shift.” Engagement was low.

After: She posted stories like “I worked 12 hours without eating and came home crying in my car. That’s when I knew I needed a new routine.” Nurses commented, shared, and started following. 

Ready to use copy psychology in your own business?

Step-by-step...

1. Think of one person you’ve helped. Picture a real client, not a general audience.

2. Write down what things looked like for them before they worked with you. What were they frustrated with? What had they already tried? What were they unsure about?

3. Now write down what changed after they worked with you. What became easier? What started to work? What did they feel more confident doing?

4. Keep it simple and specific. Use regular language. Don’t try to make it sound fancy.

5. Use what you wrote to shape your copy. These before and after details can show up on your website, in your emails, and even in how you talk about your work.

When someone sees their own situation in your "before" and their hope in your "after," they are much more likely to feel like your service is a fit for them.

They'll read more of what you write.

Once you start using psychology in your copy, people begin to respond in more meaningful ways. Instead of skimming and leaving, they stay longer and keep reading.

You might notice more replies to your emails or hear someone say, "It felt like you were talking directly to me." Your words feel relevant because they speak to what someone is actually experiencing.

Rather than focusing on what you offer, you begin focusing on what your clients are going through. Maybe they feel overwhelmed. Maybe they're unsure where to start or stuck in the middle of something they thought they could finish on their own. When your copy reflects those moments, it builds trust because the reader feels like you understand them.

Using psychology helps you move from describing your services to showing someone what life could look like after working with you.

Your message becomes a way of saying, "I understand where you are, and here's how I can help you overcome obstacles."

You don't need a background in marketing to do this well. You just need to listen closely to what people say before they choose to work with you and notice what changes for them afterward. 

Good copy doesn't rely on clever phrases or complicated frameworks. It speaks to one person who wants support and wants to feel understood.

Free Resource: Idea to Offer Formula